Dempsey & Baxter

Dempsey & Baxter has grown on a reputation for honest dealings and fair prices on the highest quality jewelry, coins, and currency. Located at 6032 Peach Street, south of the Peach and Interchange Road intersection, Dempsey & Baxter is Erie’s premier destination for engagement rings, wedding bands, jewelry gifts, custom design, jewelry repair and restoration, coins, currency, and investment bullion.  

You can shop with confidence at Dempsey & Baxter knowing that our team has accreditations from the Gemological Institute of America in most areas of the jewelry industry including diamonds and diamond grading, colored gemstones, and pearls. And with two graduate gemologists and three master jewelers on-site, you can trust that your most precious heirlooms are in good hands with Dempsey & Baxter Jewelers.  

Started in 1958 by Jack Baxter, Dempsey & Baxter is one of the only third-generation coin and currency stores in the country. We have carried coin rarities ranging from the 1913 V-Nickel to the 1999 Penny/Dime Mule. Our tremendous stock is ever changing, so there’s always something new at Dempsey & Baxter. Time to part with your treasures? We need your old coin and currency collections and will pay top dollar to acquire them! We’ve even beaten some of the biggest names in the industry to purchase collections worth hundreds of thousands and even millions of dollars! The good news is the rare coin market has never been hotter than it is right now. So even if you are just curious, the professionals at Dempsey & Baxter can tell you what your old coins and currency are worth in today’s marketplace. Dempsey & Baxter is a PCGS, NGC, CAC, and PMG authorized dealer and is a life member of the American Numismatic Association.